ǿմý

Skip to main content

The Effective Communicator: The Medium is the Message

The Effective Communicator returns to settle the never-ending debate: which form of communication is the best?

By Isaac Holyoak | 2 minutes

Dear Effective Communicator:

I get overwhelmed by all the ways to communicate with my staff: email, text message, phone, Twitter, Instagram, in-person meetings. I worry that if I don’t use the right tool, people won’t get my message—or, worse, they’ll misunderstand me. Help?

Sincerely,

Overwhelmed in my Online Office

Lime green speech bubble with the word "oy" in it.

Dear Overwhelmed,

Anyone who has ever received a break-up text (speaking for a friend), knows that how you say something can be just as important as what you say. The late Canadian media theorist Marshall McLuhan coined a brilliant phrase to describe this phenomenon: “”

The way you choose to talk to someone—the tool or medium you use—influences how that person receives your message. A belated happy birthday text from an old college friend will bring a smile to your face, while one from your spouse will turn that smile upside down.

What you say must fit with what you’re saying . It’s a concept called decorum. At first glance, it sounds old-fashioned, but (though etiquette does play a role here). Decorum also has a rhetorical, or persuasive, function.

Decorum requires a certain generosity on your part. It means approaching people the way they hope to be approached. If you’re trying to persuade your co-worker to a new point of view, speaking the way she speaks is good practice because it gives you a greater chance of reaching her.

Back to your original question: McLuhan’s phrase and the concept of decorum suggest that how you communicate to your staff depends on what you’re communicating—along with the personal preferences of who you’re communicating to . But how to know?

The best way to learn is through observation. Failing that, try asking: What’s your preference for when I communicate with you? Ask them specifically—Text? Call? Email? Walk down the hall and pop in? Especially if it's someone you will be communicating with frequently, ask them what they prefer.

I often prefer phone calls and text messages, but my colleague Kristen has a strong preference for email. We try to accommodate each other’s preferences by delivering important messages in our preferred mediums.

What About People You Can't Ask?

Data exists to guide your decisions. on Americans' communication preferences is a good indication of where you should start. The bottom line: there is a slight preference for texts and phone calls—but people still read email.

I know, I hate it too. But you can bet .

You got this,

The Effective Communicator

The Effective Communicator is Isaac Holyoak. Isaac is a contributing editor for Accelerate and leads communication for University of Utah ǿմý Medical Group. He received a Master's in rhetoric from the Brian Lamb School of Communication at Purdue University and taught speech, argumentation, and debate to undergraduates in Indiana and Texas in his pre-health care life. 

Effective Communicator's Three Quick Tips

  1. If an email is longer than your iPhone screen (and I have the small iPhone), your message probably shouldn’t be an email.
  2. I find that most people put off reading long emails. Any message that requires more than a yes or no from the recipient should probably be a phone call.
  3. When do you need an in-person meeting? When being connected, airing grievances, or understanding emotion is necessary.

More from The EC

CONTRIBUTOR

Isaac Holyoak

Editor-at-Large, Accelerate U of U ǿմý; Vice President Strategic Communications, CleanSpark